Can you freeze potato salad? If you have a lot of leftover potato salad, how do you keep the rest for later? The fact is, potato salad has a notoriously short shelf life. When kept in the fridge, it will only keep for a week. But when kept in the freezer, potato salad should keep for several months.
That being said, most chefs and culinary experts do not recommend freezing potato salad. The dairy, boiled eggs, and mayonnaise in potato salad tend to degrade quickly when frozen and defrosted. Still, it’s possible to freeze anything and as long as you have packed the potato salad well, freezing should be no problem at all.
Make sure you’ll freeze the salad in an airtight container or in a freezer bag. Don’t forget to seal it tightly. and don’t store it in the freezer for too long, as it doesn’t help with keeping the consistency of the salad anywhere near its original texture. Below is a guideline on how can you freeze potato salad:
How to Freeze Potato Salad?
Freezing Freshly Made Potato Salad
If you are making potato salad ahead of time and you are expecting a lot of leftovers, it’s best to divide the dish so you can freeze the untouched potato salad as soon as possible. To do this, prepare several large, resealable plastic bags or an airtight rigid container.
With a slotted spoon, spoon the potato salad into your preferred container. Do not overfill the container, leave about an inch or two of space. If you’re using a plastic bag, squeeze the air out before sealing. Write the storage date with a marker then stick in the freezer.
Freezing Leftover Potato Salad
Now if say, you have a little bit of potato salad leftover to freeze, remove any food debris that got mixed into the salad. If you don’t, this will speed up the degradation of the ingredients, causing the salad to go bad.
Once that’s done, get an airtight container and spoon the leftover potato salad into the container. Do not overfill the container, leave about an inch or two of space. Seal with the airtight lid, write the storage date then stick in the freezer.
Image used under Creative Commons from Stacy Spensley
Freezing Potato Salad: Common Freezing FAQs Answered
Can you freeze homemade potato salad?
Yes, you can freeze homemade potato salad but it needs careful preparation so the salad won’t turn to mush after thawing. Do note that potato salad made with oil has the tendency to take on a cloudy appearance. This won’t affect the flavor of the salad. On the other hand, homemade potato salad made with mayonnaise, eggs, or tartar sauce has an increased likelihood of bacterial growth so you have to work fast.
Since potato salad is served slightly chilled, you can prep the salad for freezing right away. To do this, prepare an airtight, freezer-friendly container. Spoon the freshly made potato salad into the container. Do not fill the container to the brim; leave about an inch of space. Cover the container with cling wrap before sealing it with the airtight lid. Write the storage date then stick in the freezer.
Can you freeze potato salad with mayo?
Most culinary experts do not recommend freezing potato salad made with mayo. Mayonnaise is made from eggs, which are a temperature sensitive ingredient. The risk of bacterial growth is just too great if the mayonnaise is left to thaw for a couple of hours in the counter. In addition, mayo could curdle when frozen and thawed. You have to re-emulsify the mayonnaise to restore its consistency. And even if you restored its consistency somewhat, it will never be the same.
Potato salad is not recommended to be frozen because it has a lot of temperature sensitive ingredients apart from mayo. But if you want to avoid waste, you can freeze the salad. Just make sure to thaw the salad carefully so the ingredients won’t go bad.
Can you freeze store-bought potato salad?
This depends on several factors. First, you need to know how long the salad was left sitting in the store. If the potato salad has been sitting in the store for a day or so, it’s no longer fresh so freezing it isn’t recommended at all. You are better off leaving no leftovers.
But if the potato salad is freshly made, then you can freeze it. This goes especially if the container is freezer-friendly and sealed. But to be on the safe side, we recommend transferring the salad in an airtight container instead of using its original packaging for freezing. The sealed container will protect the salad from freezing temps and frost.
Can you freeze German potato salad?
Definitely! German potato salad is made without mayonnaise. Instead, this salad is made with vinaigrette or vinegar, which are a terrific natural preservative. There will be a little separation between the ingredients as the frozen German potato salad thaws but just give the salad a good stir to re-incorporate the ingredients.
How to Defrost Frozen Potato Salad?
Eating frozen potato salad is no fun, you have to defrost it first. Just transfer the container from the freezer to the fridge. Leave the salad to thaw overnight.
The separation between ingredients is quite common after thawing. This goes especially for dishes that contain dairy, mayonnaise, and eggs. If such is the case, just give the potato salad a good stir to incorporate the ingredients again. Since potato salad is best served chilled, there is no need to reheat.
Who doesn’t love potato salads? As a quintessential side dish, potato salad adds a yummy dose of umami to any meal. Now that you know how can you freeze potato salad, there is no need to worry about your salad turning bad because of its short shelf life. Just freeze it!